The idea, commonly held in feminist and other left-leaning milieus, that evolutionary psychology is in every way wrong is puzzling to me.
Evolutionary psychology, at its core, is nothing but the assertion that events that occurred in the human past served to shape how we think and behave now.
For instance, an obvious one that is equally in the realm of evolutionary psychology as it is basic physiology. When humans are out in the hot sun, we tend to seek out shade quite quickly. No, this behavior isn’t coded in our genes anywhere. There is no “seek shade” gene. However, due to the way humans evolved (lack of hair, high body temperature, etc), we, as do many other animals, have an evolutionarily-based imperative to seek shade when it’s hot. Hard to deny that, and that’s evolutionary psychology just as much as the more controversial ideas in the field.
Sure, there is plenty of bad science in the ev psych arena, just as there is in every other single science out there. But if Idi Amin says the sun will rise tomorrow, that doesn’t make it wrong. The sun will still rise. By the same token, if distasteful people pervert every ev psych conclusion, that doesn’t make the entire field worthless.
I think the largest reason it’s so detested is that it occassionaly gets at truths that people don’t want to hear. No, I won’t go into these, as they have nothing to do with my argument, but I will mention the one overarching verity that is the source of all the bile.
This idea, so abhorrent to many, is that we humans are biological creatures. The revulsion towards ev psych is mostly, I believe, a reaction to that truth.
We’re messy, we often have nearly-uncontrollable urges, we die, we fuck, we’re made of dust from stars and one day we’ll be that dust again, and we’re animals just as much as a nematode, a condor, or a tamarin monkey.
People really, really don’t want to hear this, or believe it. The right, by and large, insulate themselves from this with religion, while the left typically insulates themselves from this truth by the tabula rasa myth — that is pretending biology has little (in moderate cases) to nothing (in extreme case) to do with human life and development at all.
It’s interesting to me the different tactics and methods groups and individuals take to insulate themselves from uncomfortable truths. Don’t get me wrong — I think the right-wing way is far more harmful, but that’s no reason to pretend that the left-wingers don’t do it quite often, too.
Evolutionary psyhology is one area where their insulation job really excels.
No Comments »